Government pulls plug on Asian honeybee eradication

3 03 2011

Here’s another one from the bee man, Tobias Smith (PhD candidate at the University of Queensland). Tobias recently blogged about bee basics here on (something I highly recommend for anyone interested on brushing up on bee facts and dispelling a few myths), so I asked him to follow up with this very important piece on the future of pollination in Australia. It concerns a nasty little invader recently dubbed the “flying cane toad” (not my analogy).

© 中國蜂

Over the last few weeks there has been much media attention given to the Asian honeybee (Apis cerana) incursion in far north Queensland. The Asian honeybee was first detected near Cairns in May 2007. Since then an effort to eradicate the bee has been made. This peaked during 2010, when over 40 bee eradication personnel were employed to hunt and destroy in areas around Cairns, the Atherton Tablelands, and other nearby locations.

In late January this year, the committee established to manage the eradication program (governments and industry), decided to pull the plug on eradication efforts (on money to pay for efforts that is). They decided it was no longer possible to achieve eradication (a majority decision, not a unanimous decision). The position to stop resources for eradication is not supported by industry, or ecological commentators. Arguments have been made that this is the only window of opportunity for eradication (for ever!), and that more resources need to be put towards it now, while there is still a chance of success.

A few points to be made about the Asian honeybee in Australia:

  • Over 340 colonies have been found since the original incursion in 2007 (mostly after 2009).
  • Based on the Asian honeybee’s native range, it has the potential to survive in most parts of Australia.
  • Being a cavity nester, the Asian honeybee will compete for nesting sites with native stingless bees, birds, and mammals (much as the Western honeybee (Apis mellifera) does already).
  • The bee is a little bit smaller, and behaves in a slightly different manner than the Western honeybee, so might compete with native fauna differently at floral resources.
  • Asian bees are believed to be less efficient as crop pollinators than Western honeybees, and are also known to rob Western honeybee hives of honey.
  • Industry is worried about the Asian honeybee competing with managed Western honeybee colonies.

There is also much concern about Asian honeybees being the natural carrier of the Varroa mite (which it is). However, some interesting points to be made on this are:

In early 2010 I was informed that all colonies that had been destroyed were genetic descendants from the first 2007 colony. Thus, this has all resulted from a single incursion. None of the nests found yet have been positive for Varroa, which is unsurprising because the original colony was not a carrier. I think the real Varroa worry comes if this Asian honeybee incursion does establish in Australia, as it will then be harder to detect subsequent incursions, which may carry Varroa. As I have stated on previously, Varroa only affects Apis cerana and Apis mellifera. It is potentially fatal only to Apis mellifera.

There have been comments made about this being the next cane toad or rabbit for Australia. Who knows, but it will certainly have a major impact. It will certainly be very bad for biodiversity, and it will probably be bad for agriculture. ONLY $3 million has been spent on the Asian honeybee eradication program so far.

Listen to Tim Low talk about the politics surrounding the Asian bee eradication program being stopped, on ABC Radio National Breakfast here.

Those to make demands to about putting resources towards further eradication efforts are: Federal Agriculture Minister Joe Ludwig, as well as any local members, and State and Territory politicians, in all States and Territories.

Tobias Smith



3 responses

4 03 2011
Robert Lawrence

I posted the following on the website of Joe Ludwig:

Dear Senator Ludwig
I am deeply disturbed to learn that attempts to eradicate the Asian Honeybee incursion in far north Queensland has been abandoned when this is the best time to put more resources into the program for the benefit of the whole nation.
A common problem throughout our country is for landholders with invasive species failing to take responsibility to contain and eradicate when there is opportunity.
I urge you to take responsibility for eradication of this species as a matter of utmost importance and urgency.
Yours sincerely,
Robert Lawrence


4 03 2011
Pam Kimsey

Your Asian bee sounds very similar to our now US African bee. Are they as aggressive as well? The African bee seems to be a lazy sort of bee in that it prefers to take over existing hives. There are some very awesome bee keepers here that have managed to do chemical free hives through a coarse of working the weakest bees from the hive over a series of time. They are now strong enough to clean their own bodies of the mites and said that queens are not needing to replaced for up to four years. I personally don’t see any reason commercial or otherwise should find the need to put chemicals in the hive after seeing this good news.


3 03 2011

“Thank you for your time, your comments have been successfully forwarded to Senator the Hon Joe Ludwig”

Protest has been sent to Minister Ludwig. Thank you for the heads-up Tobias!


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: