Essential role of carnivores on the wane

10 01 2014
© Luca Galuzzi

© Luca Galuzzi

This interesting review has just come out in Science, and because I was given a heads-up about it, I decided to do a F1000 recommendation. That’s more or less what follows, with some additional thoughts.

Ripple and colleagues can perhaps be excused for stating what might appear to many ‘in the biz’ to be blatantly obvious, but their in-depth review of the status of the world’s carnivores is a comprehensive overview of this essential guild’s worldwide plight. It not only represents an excellent teaching tool, the review elegantly summarises the current status of these essential ecosystem engineers.

The world’s 245 terrestrial carnivores might seem to be ecologically redundant to the informed given their natural rarity, low densities and cryptic behaviour, but nothing could be farther from the truth. Ecologists have only within the last decade or so revealed the essential ecosystem functions of these species (see former posts on here, here and here). The review focuses on the largest and most well-studied species, but the trends likely apply across most of the order.

We now know that these predators can do so much more than just limit herbivore densities – they can regulate entire ecosystems by manipulating herbivore and mesopredator densities. Indeed, a quick estimate of their trophic effect sizes reveals massive influences where they are present (compared to where they are absent). Further, the order does not represent many redundant functions given the large variation in carnivore size, density, metabolism, sociality and hunting tactics.

The role of carnivores does not end with manipulating the densities of their prey and competitors – they provide a spate of other ecosystem services: from the obvious tourism dollars (watching lions, etc.), to the less well-appreciated increase in carbon sequestration by limiting herbivore abundance and thus enhancing plant growth, and the enhancement of nutrient cycling by supporting detrivore guilds (like scavengers). Large carnivores can even benefit the industry that persecutes them the most – pastoralism – by limiting the density of wild herbivores that compete for vegetation biomass eaten by commercial livestock. They can also potentially soften the impact of climate change on other species by limiting the advance of invasive species, and by promoting regeneration of degraded vegetation as it struggles to cope with new climate extremes.

Unfortunately, these essential ecosystem engineers are extremely prone to persecution and decline/extinction. Of the 31 largest (≥ 15 kg) carnivores (excluding pinnipeds – i.e., seals, sea lions & walruses), 61 % are threatened, 77 % are declining, and the average occupancy of their original ranges is just 47 % (ranging from < 1 to 73 %).

The ages-old notion that predators should be feared and eliminated is waning, but perhaps not quickly enough before the predators themselves disappear. The evidence that they provide positive outcomes for human society is mounting and vindicates these species as vilains. Anyone doubting the essential role of carnivores needs to read this paper.

CJA Bradshaw



7 responses

7 09 2018
Minister, why is the dingo no longer ‘fauna’? |

[…] in Australia. The dingo is a keystone species that benefits small animals and plant communities by suppressing and changing the behaviours of mammalian herbivores and small-bodied predators (including foxes and cats). Their presence adds a stabilising influence and provides ecosystem […]


3 02 2016
It’s not always best to be the big fish |

[…] fewer big trees, declines of big carnivores, elephant & rhino poaching, to fishing down the web, big species tend to cop it hardest when it […]


23 09 2015
What makes all that biodiversity possible? |

[…] or via comparison of places where predators have been reduced for other reasons) can release both mesopredators and mid-trophic omnivores, thus resulting in destabilised trophic interactions and ultimately, […]


6 02 2014
Carnivorous mammals cannot get much bigger than lions | Dear Kitty. Some blog

[…] Essential role of carnivores on the wane […]


4 02 2014

Reblogged this on for Nature's sake! and commented:
Access to the original paper:


11 01 2014

[…] Bradshaw racconte un articolo uscito oggi su Science nel quale  si cerca di esaminare lo status dei grandi carnivori e i ruoli ecologici che ricoprono. Le notizie sono buone quanto quelle riguardanti […]


10 01 2014
Cagan Sekercioglu

Is not Science (and Nature) about eloquently stating “what might appear to many ‘in the biz’ to be blatantly obvious”?


Leave a Reply to What makes all that biodiversity possible? | Cancel reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: